+
Home Cooking

Why use baker's percentage to compare recipe ratios?

exex | Feb 26, 201702:36 PM     19

I have read several articles trying to understand the benefits of using the baker's percentage. Embarrassingly enough, I still don't get it! Why would you calculate proportions based on the total weight of the flour rather than the total weight of the whole dough/batter?

I like to compare different recipes a lot. Often, I want to see which one would be sweeter than the other. Why would baker's percentage be better in this situation? Wouldn't it be better to look at the weight of the whole batter, calculate % of flour, fat, sugar, and see what there is more of? If there's a lower % of sugar in one recipe, couldn't I assume it will be less sweet?

Also, if I look at the batter as a whole, I could see how much of it is taken up by the flour. I could see that one recipe has a higher percentage of flour overall, compared to another. If I use baker's percentage, flour is 100%, so I wouldn't be able to see that... Am I missing something here? Should that just not matter at all?

What's the best way to compare recipes and pick which is less sweet, but still rich, etc.?

Also, for lack of a better way of saying this, is more flour a better sweet-reducer than more fat? e.g. Recipe A: 10 sugar, 20 flour, 10 oil.
Recipe B: 10 sugar, 10 flour, 20 oil.
Which would be sweeter? Would the be pretty much the same?
i.e. does oil and flour have similar abilities to tamp down on sweetness?

Sorry for the confusing wording, I hope it makes sense.

Thanks in advance.

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

More from Chowhound

6 Budget-Friendly BBQ Tips to Save Money When Grilling This Summer
Guides

6 Budget-Friendly BBQ Tips to Save Money When Grilling This Summer

by Anna Hecht | If you're looking for ways to save money this summer while still cooking out, these affordable grilling...

17 Canning Recipes to Capture Peak Season Produce
Recipe Round-Ups

17 Canning Recipes to Capture Peak Season Produce

by Caitlin M. O'Shaughnessy | Home canning is not as complicated as you might think. Yes, it’s something pioneer women would devote...

5 Veggie Harvest Tips to Get the Most Out of Your Garden
Guides

5 Veggie Harvest Tips to Get the Most Out of Your Garden

by Debbie Wolfe | If you've gone to the trouble of nurturing a vegetable garden, make sure to harvest it so you get...

5 Tomato Plant Care Tips to Maximize Your Harvest
How To

5 Tomato Plant Care Tips to Maximize Your Harvest

by David Klein | Growing your own tomatoes is satisfying on many levels. Their season is fast and high-yielding, making...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.