Restaurants & Bars

Outer Boroughs

Bagel discovery in Astoria - Rose and Joe's


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars 4

Bagel discovery in Astoria - Rose and Joe's

bennyt | Mar 22, 2008 10:41 AM

I have long lamented the fact that good bagels are hard to come by in Astoria. Brooklyn Bagels (Ditmars and 35th st.) is decent, but I find the consistency to be a bit too doughy - the monstrous size of the bagel makes the chewy-center-to-outer-crust ratio all out whack, so that bite for bite, it's just not as bagel-y as the bagels from this city's better bagel bakeries (e.g., H and H Midtown East on the Upper East Side [not to be confused with H and H]), but it more bread-y. (Query: would their "mini-bagels" be better in this respect?)

But anyway, we recently discovered that Rose and Joe's (an Italian bakery under the elevated tracks, on 31st st. between Ditmars and 23rd Ave), which I have long recognized as making oustanding bakery style pizza and all kinds of delicious Italian cookies, breads, and pastries - the very same Rose and Joes also bakes bagels, and they're pretty darn good. They have the chewy-center-to-crust ratio down right, and the bagel has that dinstinctive barely detectable sweetness that characterizes a good New York bagel (it's the water!). The bagels are displayed in a basket behind the register, and it seems that they only bake a small quantity each day (I don't see them every time I'm in the bakery).

Anyway, I guess it shouldn't be surprising that an Italian bakery makes a good bagel, especially since I had good hamentashen from both Bruno's and Rocco's in the Village.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound