News

Recipes

Healthy

Baking

Cookbooks

Community

We and our partners use cookies to understand how you use our site, improve your experience and serve you personalized content and advertising. Read about how we use cookies and your choices here. By continuing to use this site, you accept these cookies.

General Discussion

Avocados don't ripen? Slow to turn dark and they stay hard

mushroomaffairs | Aug 22, 202006:46 AM 22
Avocados Fruit Side Dish Dip Vegetables Guacamole

My are Shoprite stores having been selling avocados every week for only $.89/ea so I've been buying a number of them. I've left some in a bowl with other fruits like bananas, apples and tomatoes and others I deposit in the fridge to ripen later.

None of the avocados on the counter have ripened and these ones are two weeks old. The skin turns dark but they stay rock hard. Normally it would take 2-5 days average to get them buttery soft in the summer but these ones don't seem to ripen. I already opened two to make guacamole, a little rotten on the stem end but the rest was ok, just hard and not ripened with softer parts here and there. The skins of these avocados are thicker than normal and they don't thin out over time.

Follow
Log In or Sign Up to comment
or

22 Comments

  1. c
    cstr i would like to see a pic. They're most likely NOT Hass. Are the skins a medium green with smoother skin? If so, the flesh...

    i would like to see a pic. They're most likely NOT Hass. Are the skins a medium green with smoother skin? If so, the flesh is very hard, but ripe.

    1. Thymus I've had that happen a few times over the years, and nothing I did to encourage ripening worked. Apparently it can happen if they...

      I've had that happen a few times over the years, and nothing I did to encourage ripening worked. Apparently it can happen if they're picked too young and/or refrigerated too early/wrong; they just stop developing. They shouldn't still be selling these things, and I'd suggest returning them.

      1. m
        maestra You could try placing a banana next to them to promote ripening, but it's likely there's nothing you can do. Bad fruit, picked too...

        You could try placing a banana next to them to promote ripening, but it's likely there's nothing you can do. Bad fruit, picked too young.
        A colleague who has an avocado orchard once told me that stringy avocados come from young trees; growing international demand means fruit is picked from trees that are not fully mature. Uneven ripening in small fruits probably has the same cause.
        The same colleague also told me not to refrigerate avocados until they are ripe. Ripen on the counter, then store in the fridge. This has worked well for me for years now. Ripe avocados last surprisingly long in the fridge.

        1. b
          blulady20 Place them on the counter inside a paper lunch sack, tightly closed. Check them every day, they will ripen rapidly. If they don...

          Place them on the counter inside a paper lunch sack, tightly closed. Check them every day, they will ripen rapidly. If they don't, return them and complain to the store manager.

          You can check for ripeness by removing the stem and checking the color underneath. If it's green, it's ripe.

          1. s
            Steve I once did a side-by-side comparison between paper bag with banana and burying it in flour. The latter ripened quicker/better...

            I once did a side-by-side comparison between paper bag with banana and burying it in flour. The latter ripened quicker/better.

            However, it sounds like these are are hopeless. That's a cheap price. I go to a hispanic market and buy large ones that are already ripe. Not cheap, but perfect, and no spoilage.

            1. m
              Mike R. re: Steve If perfectly ripe avocados are your wish, consult your favorite, high-caliber sushi restaurant. Maki / rolls with ripened, tender...

              If perfectly ripe avocados are your wish, consult your favorite, high-caliber sushi restaurant. Maki / rolls with ripened, tender, distinctive-tasting avocado are the rule at our place, just wish I knew the sourcing and method. Too many that are green on the stand, turn dark a few days later, soften nicely, but go stringy and brown and inedible soon after. Also prefer origin Mexico over Peru.

              1. m
                mushroomaffairs re: Mike R. I try to pay attention and make sure they're not from Peru. A few years ago we were getting Peruvian ones and week after week after...

                I try to pay attention and make sure they're not from Peru. A few years ago we were getting Peruvian ones and week after week after week they were horrible, wet, hard, some tasted like ass, I do remember that period and the discussions on this board. I try to make sure they're from Mexico but these ones I'm not sure.

                1. breadchick re: mushroomaffairs That's interesting. I've gotten some lately that are watery, which is a new thing for me. Never had them weep from cutting. I will...

                  That's interesting. I've gotten some lately that are watery, which is a new thing for me. Never had them weep from cutting. I will check labels from now on.

              2. m
                mushroomaffairs re: Steve I'm going to try the flour method, it sounds fun.

                I'm going to try the flour method, it sounds fun.

              3. m
                mushroomaffairs They're big avocados, they just stay hard as a rock. This is about a week and a half with a bowl of bananas and oranges. I opened...
                >

                They're big avocados, they just stay hard as a rock. This is about a week and a half with a bowl of bananas and oranges. I opened another one yesterday that felt a little soft, yet still hard, yet managed to mash pretty well so I made my usual guacamole but the guac turned brown very quickly, and not just the top but brown throughout. It tasted fine though.

                1. z
                  zackly I've been having similar problems with the cheap Mexican Hass avocados from Shoprite. They stay hard for a week or so then, if and...
                  >

                  I've been having similar problems with the cheap Mexican Hass avocados from Shoprite. They stay hard for a week or so then, if and when they soften, have a lot of brown flesh in them. I bought these just now for .89 cents each. I wonder if the problem is in the shipping or storage?

                  1. b
                    BigG re: zackly I bought an avocado six pack at WalMart a few weeks ago that suffered from this as well. I still make guac out of 'em, but it wasn...

                    I bought an avocado six pack at WalMart a few weeks ago that suffered from this as well. I still make guac out of 'em, but it wasn't the best.

                  2. Amandarama I've run into this too. If I cut into one that seems like it ought to be ready (and these are all labeled as Hass, btw), and they...

                    I've run into this too. If I cut into one that seems like it ought to be ready (and these are all labeled as Hass, btw), and they have ripened unevenly, I can kind of hack the issue by microwaving the halves for about 30 seconds on high. Take the pit out first. It's not perfect, but it salvages it enough for guac.

                    1. z
                      zackly re: Amandarama I've been sometimes buying pre-made guacamole because of this problem and it's pretty good. Sabra, Wholly or Kirkland brands.

                      I've been sometimes buying pre-made guacamole because of this problem and it's pretty good. Sabra, Wholly or Kirkland brands.

                    2. e
                      eugenep similar problems: avocado would go bad (with this black thing developing inside it once cut open) with dry texture inside without...

                      similar problems:

                      avocado would go bad (with this black thing developing inside it once cut open) with dry texture inside without ripening.

                      the weird thing is that I think grocers know this bc its only discounted avocados at a good price that does this.

                      I wonder how grocers can tell - just bc the veg didn't ripen yet or go bad yet but they know what happens next

                      1. z
                        zackly re: eugenep The big grocers probably get huge discounts on product that in abundant supply or maybe fruit that was in cold storage for a long...

                        The big grocers probably get huge discounts on product that in abundant supply or maybe fruit that was in cold storage for a long time?

                      2. b
                        BigG I think I'm going to try freezing one or two over night and seeing if they're soft the next day. Frustrating when a week after purchase...

                        I think I'm going to try freezing one or two over night and seeing if they're soft the next day. Frustrating when a week after purchase, they're not ready to guac.

                        1. Amandarama re: BigG Cool idea! Let us know if it works!

                          Cool idea! Let us know if it works!

                        2. ricepad Avocados that stay hard and rubbery were likely picked too early. While they don't ripen (soften) on the tree, they must stay on...

                          Avocados that stay hard and rubbery were likely picked too early. While they don't ripen (soften) on the tree, they must stay on the tree long enough to reach a certain maturity (I think it's a matter of having the requisite oil or fat content) before being picked. If harvested prior to the minimum maturity, they will never soften and will be inedible.

                          California state law requires that growers test their harvests to meet a minimum oil/fat content, so a "California grown" sticker will increase the chances that the avocado will transform to a buttery softness in time. Avocados grown elsewhere? Who knows.

                          1. s
                            Steve I buy avocados from my local tienda latina. They carry avocados, bananas, tomatoes that are ripe. More expensive that way but...

                            I buy avocados from my local tienda latina. They carry avocados, bananas, tomatoes that are ripe. More expensive that way but no waste. I hate waiting so long for them to ripen to only find out they're lousy. Also, that way I don't have to plan.

                            1. c
                              Cerise1 I keep avos on the countertop by themselves, and turn them every day. I don't refrigerate, or place them in a bowl with other fruits...

                              I keep avos on the countertop by themselves, and turn them every day. I don't refrigerate, or place them in a bowl with other fruits. If you can remove the stem easily, take a look underneath. If they are bright green, they are not ripe yet. If they're brown, they are overripe.

                              1. m
                                mushroomaffairs The last two visits to my local Costco and Trader Joes had really great avocados. I don't know what's going on with the ones sold...

                                The last two visits to my local Costco and Trader Joes had really great avocados. I don't know what's going on with the ones sold at Shoprite but I knew the fruit was probably going to have some wonk because of the cheap $.89 price. I won't buy them from there anymore. The funny thing about the SR avos is that they looked great. They were big and roundish and looked like they would ripen well but nope.

                                More From Chowhound

                                Guides

                                The Ultimate Spring Produce Guide: What's in Season & How to Use It

                                by Jen Wheeler | Need a spring vegetable guide to what's in season? Consider this your spring produce cheat sheet—complete...

                                Recipe Round-Ups

                                Quick and Easy Instant Pot Breakfast Recipes for Less Morning Stress

                                by Rachel Johnson | Whether the kids are still distance learning or returning to a classroom, with school back in session...

                                Guides

                                How to Care for Enameled Cast Iron So It Lasts a Lifetime

                                by Kelly Magyarics | You’ve sprung for a gorgeous piece of enameled cast iron cookware; protect your investment by cleaning...

                                Home

                                The Best Tool to Clean a Wood Cutting Board Is Probably in Your Compost Bin

                                by Debbie Wolfe | Home chefs love wood cutting boards because they are durable and reliable. Wood boards are attractive...

                                Trending Discussions

                                1
                                Chowhound Recipes That You are Saving
                                Updated 1 hour ago   |   13
                                2
                                A Final Goodbye for Chowhound
                                Updated 1 hour ago   |   234
                                3
                                Favorite Chowhound Memories
                                Updated 5 hours ago   |   53
                                4
                                NY Times: Chowhound Closes After 25 Years of Food Obsession, Wisdom and Debate
                                Updated 7 hours ago   |   1
                                5
                                January–April 2022 Baking COTM: DESSERT PERSON by Claire Saffitz
                                Updated 3 days ago   |   56
                                6
                                What are you baking these days? February 2022 Edition
                                Updated 10 days ago   |   176