+
Cookware

au gratin v. flared roasting pan v. traditional roasting pan (roaster question)

jljohn | Dec 23, 201103:18 PM     4

I am thinking through roasters and want to try to understand the pros and cons of several options. Let's assume I am considering the following options (all in the 16" range):

#1 - 16" Traditional Rectangular Roaster with straight sides in either (A) copper (tin or stainless lined) or (B) Stainless-Aluminum Tri-ply

#2 - 16" Rectangular Flared Roaster (All-Clad tri-ply from Williams Sonoma)

#3 - 16" Oval Au Gratin in either (A) copper (tin or stainless lined) or (B) Stainless-Aluminum Tri-ply

I would use this pan for two primary purposes--roasting cubed or halved sqaush and potatoes and sundry other vegetables (brussel sprouts and the like) or roasting birds. I am particularly interested in the au gratin for this purpose, as it has low, sloped sides, but I haven't found much info on the web about using such a pan as a general purpose roaster. Finally, is a tin lined pan an issue when roasting at higher temps (like when I start my turkey at 500 degrees for :30 minutes and then lower the temp)?

All thoughts would be appreciated!!!

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

More from Chowhound

Bone Broth Primer: What Exactly Is It & How Do You Make It?
Guides

Bone Broth Primer: What Exactly Is It & How Do You Make It?

by Colleen Rush | Bone broth has been having a moment...well, for a while now; we first wrote about it in 2015 when...

How to Get Your Holiday Potluck Food to the Party in One Piece
Shop

How to Get Your Holiday Potluck Food to the Party in One Piece

by Caitlin M. O'Shaughnessy and Jen Wheeler | We rounded up some of the best products for packing food and bringing it to a potluck or party—because...

Become a Christmas Cookie Professional with These Easy Tips
Guides

Become a Christmas Cookie Professional with These Easy Tips

by Danielle Valente | Santa baby, if you hurry down the chimney, chances are you’re going to be here a while munching on...

How to Ship Christmas Cookies and Other Treats
Guides

How to Ship Christmas Cookies and Other Treats

by Roxanne Webber | Merry holiday wishes alone will not protect baked goods in their travels through the mail. They can...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.