We had a so-so experience a while ago -- underdone and too-thick crust. I thought it was a one-off, and wanted to give it another try.
So we went back last week. Sweet service. Cramped tables. Nice jazz and lots of over the top holiday decor of the cheesy/plastic Santa type. But the pie? Crust on the pie was fine but it was way too cheesy. I wanted to take some of the cheese off while eating it. Ugh.
Probably won't be back in a while -- John's on Bleecker is definitely better right now (after not being great for a while) IMO.
106 W Houston St, New York, NY 10012