Just returned from ten days on this lovely island. The food was fantastic! Not one bad meal. The fish was particularly wonderful.
Our favorites, in no particular order
E's Oven - Excellent, local food in a casual home setting.
Veya - Quite special. Great meal and lovely "tree house" atmosphere
Blanchard's - Delicious and lovely
Blanchard's Beach Shack - Fantastic, super casual lunch right on the sand
Tasty's - Local and delicious.
Picante - Basic Mexican but better than anything in L.A.
Jacala - Wonderful lunch - great lobster club
Geraud's - excellent bakery