OK, just had 10 of them. (Hot). They were good. But they were not hands-down the best I've had in Manhattan. Blondie's are on the same level...one night I satisfied a Buffalo wings jones at Sarge's Deli and they were fine, too.
I guess I was expecting to get blown away by Aiello's, based on the raves I'd read here. I wasn't. Good, but not a stop I'd consistently go out of my way to make.