I just got back from Montreal and here are some reviews.
Loved, loved, loved out hotel - Hotel Nelligan. So fantastic.
Was so disapointed by Les Remparts. It was the first restaurant in so long that everything I ate was just....bad. My beau were equally unimpressed and were shocked at the poor quality and taste. Plus, the tables are on top of each other and its a quiet atmosphere so it was impossible to have a conversation without your neighbors hearing everything and vice versa.
Le Express was great - very good food - a lot more casual than I imagined - but very good.
Schwartz's was also very good - meat melted in my mouth. Instead of waiting on the line to be seated, we had a picnic in the car.
La Gargotte ??? was by far the best surprise and the best meal we had there - fresh, wholesome food, great local atmosphere and nice staff.
Hope this helps anyone visiting.