+
Home Cooking

$500 on the line with a friend in a steak cook off

Nickerz | Jul 19, 201512:45 PM     107

So I have a friend that is the "best at" everything, that we've previously bested before in a cooking competition. I know his two weaknesses are a tendency to put in too much "flair" (like whiskey in a pumpkin pie) which alienates a lot of people and also I think we'll have an execution advantage because he'll be in our home\grill.

I've got two options, of which, I think #1 is the better option.

1) Sous-Vede Rare-Medium-Rare bone-in tenderloin, blackened with brown sugar and garlic herb butter.
2) A flame grilled Wagyu Ribeye done Medium-Rare

Here's my thought pattern. Fairly certain my friend is doing a Prime Ribeye. It's going to be good, but I expect there to be some over the top rub and also probably some execution issues. I fully expect his steak to have a gradient.

I want people to look at my steak and think "that looks like something I'd see in a magazine, its cooked perfectly from edge to edge. But its too rare for my taste and its BURNT. I'm NOT going to like that."

And then when it melts in their mouth and they can not BELIEVE how wrong they are they are just blown away. I've eaten at enough high end steak places (we're down the road from a top 5 steak house in the US luckily) to know what a joy this is. It weirds me out that lots of places don't even know how to properly blacken a steak, and most people aren't even aware of it as an ordering preference. It is absolutely I think a sleeper prep.

I have a couple questions

1) Recommendations of sugar based rubs for the blackened crust
2) Your thoughts on #1 vs #2
3) Have you ever met someone that besides their preconceived bias of "not liking it bloody" ever actually said they didn't like a steak that was rare after trying it? If so, were they a girly woman type, should I eliminate them from the judging panel (dirty I know)?

Another concern I have is that I think that if I go with a strong dry age it may come off as "spoiled" to less trained taste buds. So I am considering a wet age. I'm interested to hear what you'd do in this scenario.

I want this bet to pay for all the meat and knock him down a peg. This is part of our housewarming and sort of a "pay back" to people that have hosted us in the past, so we plan on buying good stuff and making good stuff for our guests. It'd be nice if we could pay it off winning this ;)

    Image Title (Optional)
    Caption (Optional)
    Image Credit (Optional)
    Image Title (Optional)
    Caption (Optional)
    Image Credit (Optional)
    Image Title (Optional)
    Caption (Optional)
    Image Credit (Optional)

This post is locked.Have something new to say?

Create a New Post

More from Chowhound

Marie Kondo's Guide to Bento Box Lunches Your Kids Will Love
Guides

Marie Kondo's Guide to Bento Box Lunches Your Kids Will Love

by Grace Gonzalez | Marie Kondo is famous for her helpful organization hacks, and now—just in time for back to school...

Quick and Healthy Summer Recipes You Can Make with Your Kids
Recipe Round-Ups

Quick and Healthy Summer Recipes You Can Make with Your Kids

by Joey Skladany | Summer is the season of activity. Whether it's a cross-country vacation, hiking a local trail, or...

Salute Summer with these 15 Gin and Tonic Variations
Drink

Salute Summer with these 15 Gin and Tonic Variations

by Amy Sowder | Looking for some interesting spins on the classic gin and tonic? Rosé and the Aperol Spritz may be...

These Wine Coolers Are Not the Ones You Drank in College
Recipe Round-Ups

These Wine Coolers Are Not the Ones You Drank in College

by Chowhound Editors | One upon a time, the wine cooler—a pour of Chablis from the jug, topped off with fizzy water—was the...

Trending Discussions

1

Encroyable!

Updated 3 hours ago 2 comments
2

Cleaning your fish

Updated 13 hours ago 3 comments
3

Mac and Cheese lovers?

Updated 23 minutes ago 9 comments
4

The perfect crumble?

Updated 21 hours ago 2 comments

See what's new!

View latest discussions ›

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.