Beer, Cider, & Sake

2013 Bigfood vs. Foghorn: Barleywine blind tasting 1 year after release.

TombstoneShadow | Dec 15, 201310:23 PM     13

Okay, in anticipation of the 2014 barleywine season just ahead, thought I'd do a heads-up blind tasting of two flagships: the 2013 Sierra Nevada Bigfoot and Anchor Old Foghorn.

Actual tasting notes follow:
Foghorn vs. Bigfoot, 2013, released Feb 2013. Tasted Dec. 2013 Blind.

1: Nice initial luscious taste, medium viscosity… but gives way to a bit of a lingering “swamp beer” flavor…. i.e. more of a pale ale backnote.

2: Greater depth of flavor… somewhat more lip-smacking…

1: Back to 1, a bit sweeter on second tasting… and the swamp note has cleared out (decanted?). Definitely more viscous, 2 is a bit more carbonated in texture….

Bottom line… after sipping back and forth, I’m definitely going with 1 due to extra sweetness… which the 2 never really achieves, remaining on the drier side throughout.

Nothing is meant to say that 1 is particularly great, but it is overall solid and relatively better on my palate for what I'm looking for in a barleywine.

1: Old Foghorn 2013
2: Bigfoot 2013

I should note this is consistent with my palate preferences between these two going back over at least the past 10 years.

BTW: Anyone know if Foghorn changed their recipe at all since going to the larger 12oz bottle instead of those smaller bottles they used to use? There was a cache to those small bottles like they "seemed" more concentrated, though the flavor seems the same.

I really like this beer, might not be quite my #1 barleywine but it's a go-to everytime and alot more accessible than greats like 3 Floyds Behemoth or Old Horizontal which just don't stay on the shelf... It's got the sweetness, the sticky viscosity, the complexity, love this stuff....

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

More from Chowhound

Target Launches New Line of "Clean" Home Cleaning Products
Food Trends

Target Launches New Line of "Clean" Home Cleaning Products

by David Watsky | Target has announced a new line of clean home cleaning products, Everspring. The environmentally friendly...

The Ultimate Guide to Picnicking

The Ultimate Guide to Picnicking

by Chowhound Editors | The picnic is one of the annual joys of warm-weather (and sometimes cool-weather) eating, and our...

Celebrate Spring with These Harvest Salad Recipes
Recipe Round-Ups

Celebrate Spring with These Harvest Salad Recipes

by Miki Kawasaki | Summer may seem like prime time for salads, but fresh spring produce also shines in simple preparations...

Celebrate Spring with These Seasonal Cocktails
Recipe Round-Ups

Celebrate Spring with These Seasonal Cocktails

by Brittany Loggins | There’s no better way to shed your winter layers and ease into spring than with a delicious cocktail...

Trending Discussions


Pasta Noodles - Boil them or no?

Updated 11 minutes ago 4 comments

Super Wet Pizza Dough

Updated 18 minutes ago 5 comments

Hello Chowhounds!

Updated 2 hours ago 2 comments

See what's new!

View latest discussions ›

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.