My company brings trainees into NJ for training seasonally, and into NYC for one night. Normally they've taken them to Carmine's in Times Square, but my boss is open for something else if I have a better idea. Budget around $50-60 not counting drinks. She wants it to be "a quintessential NYC place"...I'd love to do Otto and their group menu looks budget-friendly, but I welcome all suggestions. This will be the first trip to NYC for many of these recent college grads. Total party size will be 12-14.