Have not eaten at either and have a single opportunity to go relatively no holds barred (no limit on food, probably a self imposed $250 or so limit on wine) one evening next week. I have winnowed down my thoughts to these 2, by all accounts, spectacular choices. Dinner will simply be myself and my wife (in our mid 30's) with the intention of having a quietly celebratory and romantic (but not in an over the top way:)) evening. Any thoughts out there on preferences? A 3rd option that i have overlooked? Any help would be greatly appreciated! Thanks so much!