Wilkin & Sons Ltd. Tiptree Organic Tomato Ketchup is a bottled ketchup that actually tastes like tomatoes, says lisavf. The tomato content is 75 percent, and the other ingredients are sugar, wine vinegar, salt, lemon juice, and spices. It’s thick and very tomatoey, says lisavf, and at $6.99 a bottle it’s definitely an adult condiment; the cheap stuff is fine for the kids, and for baking into meatloaf.

Harters prefers Tracklements Tomato & Pepper Ketchup. It has “a slight backnote of chili. Great with your fish finger sandwiches,” he says. And steakman55 recommends Heinz Organic.

Board Links: I found a really good bottled ketchup

See more articles