It’s hard for me to walk through New York’s Chelsea Market without making a pit stop at Fat Witch for the near-perfect brownies. But there are only so many brownie bites—caramel, blondie, or walnut—a girl can justifiably eat. Luckily, the last time I was in NYC it was the start of Witchino season, so I enjoyed my brownies in a frozen drink. The Witchino is like Starbucks’ Frappuccino made with brownies and good cacao but without the excessive sugar. The flavors change daily: When I visited last, the shop was serving both chai and toffee versions. The toffee Witchino was buttery, chocolaty, cooling, creamy, and indulgent.