The house specialty at Mr. Tod’s Pie Factory is sweet potato—and it’s the best version jerzeegyrl’s sweet-potato-pie-loving husband has tasted. Pecan pies are good, too, she adds. jerzeegyrl faults only the apple pie, for its spicing and for a dense, copious filling that strains the relatively thin butter crust. Fruit cobblers and cheesecake are also on the menu.

Call and order ahead, she advises, especially around holidays.

Mr. Tod’s Pie Factory [Somerset County]
1760 Easton Avenue (near Cedar Grove Lane), Somerset, NJ

Board Link: Mr. Tod’s Pie Factory: Sweet Potato Pie

See more articles