The old-school New York slice, a dying breed, is alive and kicking at Alfie’s Pizza in Queens. “As good a slice (not pie) as I’ve ever had,” reckons NAtiveNewYorker. “If you travel for good pizza, try them.”

Some caveats: Pass on the pedestrian calzones and heros. Skip the second-rate pizza toppings, like canned mushrooms. Just stick to the plain slice, which kills.

Alfie’s Pizza [Richmond Hill]
86-08 117th Street (near Myrtle Avenue), Richmond Hill, Queens

Board Links: Alfie’s Pizza-GREAT
I’ve done DiFara’s but who is #2

See more articles