best mail order pies
All featured products are curated independently by our editors. When you buy something through our retail links, we may receive a commission.

It seemed like a great idea at first: pies are a must on the holiday table so why not bake a couple from scratch? But you still have to run out and do some last minute shopping. And you’re definitely going to hit the grocery store a few more times (it doesn’t help that your nephew decided to go full keto recently). Oh, and now the oven is acting up. The great news is you can avoid all the insanity that is making pies by ordering one from a pro directly to your door.

Savannah’s Southern Pecan Pie by Savannah’s Candy Kitchen, 2 for $79.95

Savannah’s Candy Kitchen

You certainly can’t go wrong by serving a slice of Southern hospitality. This particular pecan pie features a delightfully gooey center and is topped, of course, with a crunchy layer of homegrown Georgia pecans.  Buy Now

S’mores Pie by Butter & Scotch, $42

Butter & Scotch

This New York bar and bakery had an instant hit when it introduced its Instagram-worthy S’mores Pie. A graham cracker crust and creamy chocolate filling provide the foundation to a roasty, toasty marshmallow topping.Buy Now

Crack Pie by Milk Bar, $48

Milk Bar Crack Pie mail order

Milk Bar

Crack is not whack, at least when it comes the signature pie from Christina Tosi’s Milk Bar. This sinfully sweet and salty creation is housed in an oat cookie pie crust and finished off with a light dusting of powdered sugar. It’s sure to be a crowd pleaser at your holiday gathering provided there aren’t any dentists at the table.Buy Now

Chicken Pie by Centerville Pie Company, $64

Oprah's favorite chicken pie


Yes, this savory pie option has Oprah’s seal of approval and no, it does not have a cauliflower crust. You’ll only find hand-pulled chicken, homemade gravy, and seasoning (sorry vegetables, no room for you) in this pie, which feeds six to eight people and can easily stand in as the main event for your holiday dinner.  Buy Now

Cocoa Chanel Chess Pie by Muddy’s Bake Shop, $39 at Goldbelly

Muddy's chocolate chess pie


Arguably from the best bakery in Memphis. Chess pie is a no-frills custard-based staple of the South but Muddy’s presents an elevated take on this classic. The ultra-rich, fudgy filling and flaky, all-butter crust simply can’t be beat.  Buy Now

Maple Wicked Whoopie by Wicked Whoopies, 12 for $30

Wicked Whoopies

Amy Bouchard has been making whoopie pies for over two decades. In fact, her company Wicked Whoopies has produced over 30 million of the beloved hand-held treats. Wicked’s pies come in a variety of flavors but their maple version featuring rounds of syrup-infused cake filled with fluffy cream is a favorite for the holidays.  Buy Now

Kermit’s Key Lime Pie by Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe, $38.95

Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe

Kermit’s Key Lime Pie is the best in Key West, or anywhere else for that matter. Local key limes are the key (oh, dad puns!) to a bright, tart filling that complements the pie’s signature graham cracker crust. A ring of whipped cream offers just the right touch of sweetness.  Buy Now

Dutch Apple by Julian Pie Company, $20.95

Julian Pie

The Smothers Family knows a thing or two about apple pie. Not only do they continue to run the Julian Pie Company, the Southern California institution which they founded over 32 years ago, they even bought their own apple orchard. Not surprisingly, apple finds its way into nearly all of the bakery’s pies, but the Dutch version, which features a crunchy crumb topping, is a standout.  Buy Now

Harry and David Deep Dish Pumpkin Pie, $49.99

Harry and David deep dish pumpkin pie

Harry and David

An extra-thick layer of creamy pumpkin pie filling is topped off with fluffy whipped cream. It’s a classic, but even more of it than usual, and there’s nothing wrong with that. You can also order a gluten-free pumpkin pie, though it’s not deep dish.Buy Now 

 Sugar Cream “Hoosier Sugar Pie” by My Sugar Pie, $28

My Sugar Pie

If you’ve never heard of Hoosier Pie, it’s time to get familiar. This version is the perfect introduction to Indiana’s state pie. My Sugar Pie keeps things traditional with the trinity of butter, sugar, and cream. This is the kind of slice that after taking one bite you’ll be asking, “Where have you been all my life?”  Buy Now

For more great gift ideas, see our Gourmet Food and Drink Gift Guide, and our Best Kitchen Gadgets, Tools, and Appliances Gift Guide.

Related Video: The World’s Fastest Pumpkin Pie

Header image courtesy of Savannah Candy Kitchen

David is a food and culture writer based in Los Angeles by way of New York City. His work has appeared in the Los Angeles Times, CBS Local, Mashable, and Gawker.
See more articles