mustache cupcake toppers
All featured products are curated independently by our editors. When you buy something through our retail links, we may receive a commission.

Let’s say you’ve planned the perfect Father’s Day meal. You’ve grilled all his favorite foods for dinner and bought him the whiskey of his dreams to have with it. There’s only one not-so-minor detail you haven’t yet figured out–dessert. You could go with a Fudgie the Whale ice cream cake or classic strawberry shortcake. But maybe you want something just a little bit different this year.

Related Reading: Father’s Day 2020 Gift Guide: Find the Perfect Gift for Dad

If your dad is anything like ours, he’s probably got a mustache that rivals Alex Trebek. Why not use the last course of your meal to honor his stylish, walrus-like facial hair? Whether it’s cookies, cake, or chocolate, there’s no sweet that can’t be converted into dad-famous whiskers. We’ve scoured the internet to find some of the best recipes and products to inspire you. Check them out below.

Give Pops Chocolate Mustache Pops

These adorable chocolate mustaches can be worn by the whole family. They’re also highly customizable and can be decorated with a variety of sprinkles and toppings. If only we could don M&M’s on our face in real life! The instructions also include a downloadable template with every mustache variation under the sun, so you can try them all on. The swirly handlebar may be the sweetest of them all. Get the Chocolate Mustache Pops recipe.

Make Dad Mustache Cookies

These sugar cookies are relatively easy to make. In terms of design, a mustache cookie cutter does most of the heavy lifting. Be careful to pipe the icing to get the perfect wavy texture though. Or go wild with your own patterns. Get the Mustache Cookies recipe.

Ann Clark Mustache Cookie Cutter, $5.99 on Amazon

Buy Now

Cut Up a Mustache Cake

It’s actually really easy to cut a cake into the shape of a mustache. Simply bake a cake in a round tin and slice an s-shaped curve down the middle. Then put the two pieces side-by-side. It’s a nifty shortcut that will impress all your friends, and maybe even dad himself. If you’re feeling extra fancy, pipe individual tufts of frosting to get a super-detailed texture. It’ll look almost as bushy as the real thing. Get the Mustache Cake recipe and detailed cutting instructions here.

Bake Cupcakes with Mustache Cupcake Toppers

mustache cupcake toppers

Christine Jewels 5/Etsy

Maybe you just don’t have time for intricate frosting techniques. Cheat a little by making dad’s favorite cupcakes and then top them off with some paper mustache cut-outs. We swear he won’t mind. After all, it’s the thought that counts. Try our Chocolate Guinness Cupcakes recipe, or whatever dad likes, then put these dandy little mustache picks in the top to let him know they’re in his honor. (And if he’s a fancy dad, try these glitter mustache cupcake toppers, which you can order in a rainbow of colors too.)Buy Now

Unmold Mustache Ice Cubes (or Chocolates)


Use this nifty ice cube tray to mold your favorite frozen desserts into an assortment of facial hair masterpieces. Fu Manchu sorbet or Yosemite Sam ice cream is the perfect way to bring dad’s big day to close. Or just add a handlebar-shaped ice cube to his favorite cocktail for some extra flair.

Related Reading: The Best Gifts for Dads Who Like Their Booze

Buy Now

Microwave a Mustache Coffee Mug Mug Cake


You can’t have cake without coffee. And you can’t have coffee without mustached coffee cups! Get some mugs that go with the theme to complete your meal. Bonus points if you can sculpt a mustache pattern into the latte foam—or take the easy route and make dad a mug cake in his new mustache cup.Buy Now

More Great Gift Ideas

Find the Perfect Father's Day Present for Your Dad

Header image courtesy of Christine Jewels 5/Etsy

See more articles