I nominate Sam's Famous Pizza on the corner of 116th Lex.
It's like eating a slice of papier mache with sugar water and latex on top of it.
Got out of the train there the other day, heard the guys speaking Italian behind the counter, felt like a slice....why not? Got my slice took a bite. Incredulous, I took another bite. I looked the older Italian guy in the face, scowled slightly, and threw the slice in the trash can as he watched. He shrugged his shoulders and I walked out.
Hall of shame.
Please nominate your candidates for worst pizza slice in Manhattan/pizza hall of shame here.
Sam's Famous Pizza
150 E 116th St, New York, NY 10029