Chowhound Presents: Table Talk with Michael Pollan of The Omnivore’s Dilemma Tenth Anniversary Edition

Home Cooking


Best type of apples to use for pie?


Home Cooking 11

Best type of apples to use for pie?

Diane in Bexley | Sep 24, 2012 09:53 AM

Last night I made an apple pie using Granny Smith apples. They were huge, I peeled, cored them and cut them in eighths. Tossed them with sugar, cinnamon and a little flour adding some pats of butter. Put on the top crust and cut a few slits. The pie turned out beautiful in appearance, crisp and golden brown, the pastry was delicious. The filling was disappointing. What looked like a nice, high apple pie prior to baking shrunk. The pastry was still high, but there was a large gap to where the filling reached the pie crust, the apples had cooked down to not much at all. The apple filling didn't taste right, very flat. I had tasted the raw apples and they seemed fine.

What type of apples make the best pie? I have access to a farm fruit stand and was thinking of buying a big box of Cortlands, are these good pie apples? They carry other types as well. What kind of apples should I buy for pies, crisps, baking? Thanks!

Want to stay up to date with this post?