So clearly I've been living under a rock. Because although Arturo's might not be the best pizza in all of New York, it is definitely the best delivery in the West Village, IMO. We've only had pizza there twice and each time tried a variety of their toppings (as they have so many and the quality is definitely above average). But so many choices! What have you had that's been great? Or bad? Always up to try someone else's creative (or not so creative) concotion.
P.S. How is their pepperoni? De Marco's is the only place I found that hand slices it so that it's on the thicker side and not paper thin slices of bland smokey grease.