I have a reservation at both Mr. P's and Live Oak Cafe this Saturday night and I don't know which one to pick. I've done A LOT of research on both, and I'm finding mixed reviews. I've asked both to fax menus, but I haven't heard back from one and can't get in touch with anyone at the other.
This is a very special weekend - price is not an issue, but eating good, fresh seafood is.
So, which of these two would you choose, and why?