I'll be in E. Hampton this weekend and would like to try to make detours to Shelter Island (never been) and Montauk (drove once to the lighthouse and back). I have a bridal shower that will probably take all of Sunday but will be free to wander around all the forks from Thurs. nite - Sat.
Looking for dinner suggestions Thurs. nite on Shelter Island. I'm guessing I'll be in that part of Long Island hopefully by 3 or 4 pm so it will give me time to hop the ferry and explore on foot. Any interesting places that focus on fish or seafood? Or casual spots with interesting views? What about reservation policies? Will it be easy to dine as a walk-in on a Thursday night? Looking to have dinner around 7:30ish or so. I'm also concerned about timing and making the last ferry back to the Hamptons.
Also looking for a nice breakfast or lunch place in Sag Harbor on Friday or Saturday. I've been to the Hotel in the village for brunch and am looking for something similar. Cute, historic, charming or quaint?
And good seafood shacks in Montauk?