Ambergris Caye gets a bad rep as a haven for miscreants, John McAfee being the most recent. The island is safe, and the restaurants are good by any Caribbean standard. Victoria House, south of town, is 3 stars. In town, Fido's conch fritters, Vagabundos's lobster burrito, and everything at Elvi's Kitchen and Celi's is good. North across the cut, Capricorn is 3 stars. Freshest stone crabs you will find, from Caye Caulker that morning. Good wine list, also.