Just learned of this site from New Yorker magazine (Trillin article)--Extremely happy to find out about it . . .but will this attract the right type of interest?
Have lived in San Diego 10 years, New York and LA before that. Am just working my way through the message board but want to comment on a few of the messages.
1. Agree ref: Eleanor Widmer--she was an abomination as a critic. However, is anybody more happy with Naomi Wise? I find her reviews long, boring, and not terribly informative. Seems amazing that she was a San Francisco critic. Max Nash was better--very knowledgeable but seemed to limit his reviewing to Asian places. Why doesn't San Diego have a decent critic?
2. Authentic tacos in San Diego (pastor, cabeza, etc)--El Napolita (off the I-5) at Santa Fe exit. Attracts all the Mexican workers at lunch--try it. They also have a tortilla factory on site.
3. El Callejon in Cardiff makes a fish vera cruz that is as good as any that I've had in Ensenada. Try all their Mexican Seafood (esp. shrimp dishes).
4. Thanks for tip on Candelas--I intend to try it this week.
5. Mimmo's sandwich shop next to downtown courthouse--all the cops and attorneys eat there at lunch. Fresh baked bread, awesome sandwiches (try the grilled cheese feta and the tunisian).
6. I have to respectfully disagree about Extraordinary Desserts--pompous, precious, overpriced, and too expensive. I think it appeals because there's nothing better as an exclusive dessert place.
7. Tapenade in La Jolla is a terrific, although expensive French Provencal. However, try their early bird $25 3 course dinner.