I just returned from a weekend vacation with my girlfriend in Pittsburgh. I had a great foodie weekend thanks to all of the Chowhound posts and Yelp reviews. Here's a list of the places I visited and my opinion of each restaurant. I hope my reviews can help future chowhounds visiting Pittsburgh:
Salt of the Earth (4.5 out of 5.0 stars): My girlfriend had the gazpacho and the salmon and I had the cockscombs and cod. The gazpacho, salmon, and cockscombs dishes were outstanding and very unique to say the least. My cod entree was way too spicy for my taste. I felt that the spiciness overpowered the cod and the other elements of the dish. I love the concept of Salt (no menus, no bread, laid back atmosphere, etc.) and the first floor seating. I sat on the 2nd floor and don't recommend it because it is very dark and you lose a bit of the atmosphere of the restaurant. I like the fact that Salt wants to push the envelope of what food can be and show that it can be done in a casual atmosphere. Also note that the parking at Salt is non-existent. You have to park in the surrounding neighborhoods, but I was lucky enough to have the valet guys next door take my car.
Eleven (5 out of 5 stars): I went to Eleven for dessert after Salt and I was blown away by the banana cream pie and the chocolate peanut pretzel candy bar. Probably some of the best desserts I have ever had. I also recommend the Teajito drink at Eleven.
Dinette (5 out of 5 stars): I wish all restaurants were modeled after Dinette. I appreciate the fact that Dinette is focused on using local ingredients as much as possible (with some from the rooftop garden). I had the grilled chicken wings, prosciutto pizza, the fresh ricotta pizza, and the arborio rice dessert. All were outstanding and unique to say the least. I didn't think pizza could taste like this until I visited Dinette. The bread-sticks that come with the meal are awesome too. Highly recommend. It seems that some people love Dinette while others hate the restaurant because of the prices and size of the pizzas. I fall in the group of loving Dinette and I don't think the prices were outrageous for the quality.
Reyna's Taco Stand (5 out of 5 stars): I had the beef tongue and chorizo tacos and they were the best I have ever had. The aguas frescas were awesome as well. Highly highly recommend the taco stand. And for $3.00 a taco, you can't go wrong.
Lucy's Bahn Mi Stand (5 out of 5 stars): I've never had a Bahn Mi before, but the one they sell at this non-descript stand is probably the best sandwich I have ever eaten. The BBQ pork goes so well with the cilantro, carrots, and onions. The stand is right in front of the Firehouse Lounge on 2216 Penn Avenue. I never would have found this place if it wasn't for Chowhound. Awesome can't even begin to describe how good this sandwich is.
Spoon (5 out of 5 stars): Spoon is like Salt of the Earth, but with food that is more "in the box". I went there on a Sunday night and the place was half full. I had the "fried chicken", grilled fillet + shortribs, and the strawberry tart. My girlfriend had the blue cheese souffle, the scallops, and the death by chocolate dessert. None of the food blew me away (except for the souffle and the strawberry tart), but all of it was well executed and tasted great. Expensive, but worth the money. The service was wonderful as well. I was concerned that there would be issues having one kitchen for 2 restaurants (Spoon and BRGR use the same kitchen), but they kitchen didn't miss a beat.
Kaya (3.5 out of 5 stars): Kaya sells good food, but nothing that was memorable. The conch fritters were good, the slow cooked pork and banana sandwich was good, the sweet potato fries that came with the sandwich was good, and the limeade drink was good. The service was good as well. None of the food was memorable and I've had food like this at other restaurants. There are definitely better food options in Pittsburgh.
Espresso a Mano (5 out of 5 stars): Probably the best espresso drinks I have ever had. The fact that it takes the barista 10 minutes to make 2 drinks shows you how much they focus on quality. And the fact that they guy can pour the milk into the shape of a leaf into my espresso shows you how much skill he has.
Peace, Love, and Little Donuts (4.5 out of 5 stars): I really like this place. The donuts aren't the cheapest, but they taste great. If you go for donuts, get the half dozen to get the cheaper prices.
There you have it. My review of places I have eaten in Pittsburgh. I'll probably visit Il Pizzaiolo and Kous Kous cafe the next time I'm in town. If you have any questions about the food I ate, feel free to ask me.
1301 Merchant St, Ambridge, PA 15003
703 Washington Rd, Pittsburgh, PA 15228