While driving back to NY from Acadia this past weekend my girlfriend and I decided to stop at Reds for what was promised as the best lobster roll around. The wait was excrutiating, almost an hour for a lobster roll that was good but not great. My gf and I both prfer Biels in Acadia and Abotts in Noank. The lobster at Reds was not as fresh as those 2 places and although you get a ton of lobster it just didn't do it for me.
On another note, our favorite lobster in Acadia was at Abels - absolutley amazing and incrediblly fresh.