Thanks everyone for the great responses on my original post. I have five nights in town and have narrowed the list down somewhat. Appreciate any thoughts as I'm one dinner too many. I tried to group decisions so not eating Italian everynight, etc. For background, we're big foodies that use to live in NYC (miss it alot) and likely will have a couple friends with us each night.
1) Del Posto, Apizz or Babbo (love Il Buco but trying to branch out)
2) Market Table, Little Owl or Blue Hill Restaurant
3) Allen and Delancey
5) Perry Street
6) Peter Luger's (believe it or not, in all our years in NY we never made it to Luger's)
For lunch we're thinking Spotted Pig and Momofuku Ssam Bar.