I've known about this place for a long time, but it's not really on anyone's way anywhere. It's on a sidestreet in a residential neighborhood, not open on weekends, doesn't advertise, has no display cases, and is *tiny*. They could have subbed this exterior for Satriale's in the Sopranos lead-in.
You order what you want from: (a) what you already *know* you want; or (b) from a printed sheet. Then they bring it to you. Unless you're standing waiting for someone else's order to be filled or something of yours trimmed, you don't even see any meat! Most of the time the place looks like a vintage butcher tool museum.
But I found out that they really move the meat, provisioning a huge % of the local and Alaska-bound fishing fleets (all but 2 of the crabbers on Deadliest Catch are provisioned by BM). Retail sales are welcome, but you get the impression as a walk-in retail customer that you're the tip of a very large iceberg.
I walked out with 5 lbs. of the best-looking, -trimmed, and -tasting stew meat I've had in years ($5.95/lb.) for a special Ragu, and 2 lbs. of lean bacon ($4.79/lb.). Other example prices are: 80/20 ground beef ($3.89), lamb leg ($6.89), Oxtail ($5.29), veal bones ($3.99), bulk duck fat, and NY steak, ($12.95).
I'm going to cook and eat my way through their entire list of offerings (including my Holiday Spencer Roll Roast ($14.95), but from others who may be more familiar with Better Meat, what do you recommend?