Went to Maui for a week. I thought some of these info can help the next CH going to the island paradise.
Mama's Fish House is our first stop as our flight arrived at lunchtime. I still think lunch is really the best time to go there - easier to get a table close to the window for a view, and you can actually see the ocean (unlike if you go at night). I think it's our 4th or 5th time there. The prices increased again, and some of the prices are a bit astronomical now. Tropical drinks are $16, but an iced tea is a somewhat reasonable $3 alternative. My favorite go-to dish is the stuffed mahi with crab and lobster, and it's $50+ now. With that said, if you opt not to have the expensive drinks, and stick with sharing an appetizer and go without dessert, it's not too bad. Our tab with 2 ice teas, 1 appetizer, 2 entrees, 1 kid's meal ($15) totals about $160 with tax and tip.
The food was ultra fresh and delicious as usual. We got the crabcake appetizer with a tomato based salsa and it was light and flavorful. Hubbie got the seared ahi which came with a kalua pork rice side. Service was good as usual and the view was just spectacular. We skipped dessert as we were going to try the Guri Guri.
Pictured are the mahi and the seared tuna.