So now that we've deduced that Haldimand has slim pickin's for good food....I've decided that since this area is a cottage/tourist destination in Summer full of unknowing diners to save a few of you time and money and tell you my opinions on area dining experiences...;-)
First on the list has to be the Sunflower Cafe. What can I say about a place that can't even make scrambled eggs? Have never had a good meal here and only went back because someone else was buying (and we don't have anything else in town). The food seems to be frozen, often, and there is no pride in their product-it's very obvious. They seem to count on the fact that they are the only option in town, but I'd rather go hungry.
Hagersville restaurant. Even after asking the waitress for her candid opinion on the alfredo (sometimes they'd rather avoid a dissatisfied patron and just be honest) she assured me "people like it". I have to say WHAT people? The people without tatsebuds? Starving people? Who, exactly, likes to eat wallpaper paste? All the pepper and parmesan on the table couldn't make it edible. Again if a friend wasn't buying (and is the type to be easily embarassed) I would have refused to pay for that slop.
I have had hit and miss experiences at Hoover's marina. It does have a nice ambiance, being right on the water with a patio, but the food has been good here and not good, maybe depending on who is working? A server once tried to tell my (professional fisherman) friend that he was being served (and charged for) pickeral when it wasn't pickeral...why not just be honest and say "We are out of that at he moment?" Most times service is OK, I prefer to just stop here for a beer and maybe some sweet potato fries.
Floyd's, in Nanticoke, is a home cookin' type of place. The daily specials are fresh and homemade, nothing fancy but a decent meal for a decent price. The perch has a good batter, not too bready, in short have not been dissatisfied here.
The Cheapside Restaurant has a good breakfast, if a bit slow to get to the table. Have not eaten lunch or dinner here so can't comment on that, but I do appreciate the open kitchen....nothing to hide with their cleanliness or prep.
Farther out there is the Dog's Nest south of Simco. Food was enjoyable, and menu varied, on only one dining experience I'd have to say I'd go back again.
Anyways, just a bit of food for thought if you're heading this way this Summer...;-)