After spending 3 days on the West End and enjoying Ortanique, Agua, Sunshine Grill (where we were staying) and almost Eduardo's (where we both enjoyed our meal but suffered stomach upset immed'ly after getting back to our room) - we've relocated to Boddentown. Looking for recs around here to the East End for everything from breakfast to dinner, beach shacks to high end, so long as the food is good! We have a car.
I didn't see much on the boards so decided to wing our first dinner here. A fellow guest at Turtle Nest Inn said they had really enjoyed their dinner at Tukka on the East End. Big mistake -- it was hands down the worst meal we've had since getting here and it wasn't cheap! Dry, tasteless food. My husband agreed we could get better takeout in NYC for about 1/5 of the price!
Our hotel suggested we try South Coast, which is nearby. Any thoughts or should we go running back to the West End restaurants? Thank you for your thoughts!