I visited the Good Life (no longer called Downtown, as it's the only one lelft) about a year ago after new owners took over, and left disgusted: that meal was gross. New chef Michael Scelfo, late of the Hound-beloved North Street Grill, is now in the kitchen, and his food is a huge improvement, mostly very, very good on its own terms.
First-floor bar is packed all night, downstairs vodka bar (200 selections) with DJ booth probably only fills up on weekends, presumably drawing a crowd that likes its booze watermelon- or caramel-flavored. Dining room stays mostly empty all night, so we get the server's rapt attention. We try a bunch of dishes, all of them very good and fairly priced:
* Pizza, one of several medium-crust, slightly fancy, 11" numbers, ours with shaved apple, carmelized onions, good smoked Cheddar, quite nice
* A appetizer-sized (but not tiny) pressed sandwich of duck, slaw studded with sour cherries, and Gruyere, very tasty
* An enormous deconstructed almost-Caesar salad with speck and pickled onions
* A beautiful spaghetti Carbonara described as having a "sparkling egg sauce"; the sparkle, from alleged Prosecco, isn't evident, but the intact yolk atop it, which we stir in, is, a delicious and authentic touch; there's lots of good Kurobuta bacon, too.
* A side of mac and cheese: a goodly portion of rich, creamy, sharp-cheesed elbows, very nice. There's an even bigger app-sized version with foie gras and mushrooms, but we're already overordering.
* Generous-sized sides of frites (good, clearly twice-fried, faintly rosemary-dusted) and roasted asparagus
* A not-very-pressed Cubano with the ham MIA, pretty respectable carnitas instead of roast pork loin, avocado (!) and sweet pickles; not quite Chez Henri good, but rather huge and pretty tasty (but $14)
* A banana bread pudding with caramel sauce that is good, but lacking the texture we seek in the best versions of this dessert.
While I'm not still dreaming about any of these a few days later, there is a consistency and minor note of creativity in these dishes that make us feel like it's a good deal, and worth returning to. Good prices for Downtown Crossing: apps in high single digits, pies around $12, entrees (including sandwiches) mostly mid-teens, sides and desserts around $6.
Cocktails are decent, though served in ugly, colored-stem cocktail glasses. A very short list of okay wines at okay prices.
I hope more folks find there way here to fill up that dining room. It's now one of the better Western dining options near Downtown Crossing.