Chowhound Presents: |

Restaurants & Bars

Manhattan

For GF's Bday, best steak in Manhattan

Share:

More from Restaurants & Bars

Restaurants & Bars Manhattan

For GF's Bday, best steak in Manhattan

f
fishermb | | Oct 26, 2008 06:39 PM

Hey All, my girlfriend's birthday is coming up the first week of December so I'm starting to get some plans together. She doesn't eat red meat very often, but she requested a steak dinner. I've read several threads where everyone argues about the best steak, it's too much for me to take in, and as someone who doesn't eat red meat, I don't really have any experience on the subject, I thought I'd just post some basics of what we're looking for...

Price isn't a big deal, I imagine this will probably be a $200-250 dinner for us with drinks no matter where we wind up. We're in our mid-20s, so we'd prefer to go to some place with a bit of ambiance, although when it comes down to it, the food (read: the steak) is the most important. This will be for a Sunday night at 7:30PM so I don't think reservations will be impossible anywhere, but I'd like to firm up the plans ASAP.

Keens seems like it always has great reviews, but the location seems terrible.GF has mentioned her desire to go to craftsteak, but I think I've read too many conflicting reviews to risk her meal not being top notch. It might come down to Luger's, though I know she'd prefer to stay in Manhattan. Help!

Feedback