I am going to be in NYC for New Years, and I am in charge of organizing a dinner for 8 guys. We are in our early 20s (seniors in college) and all have a strong appreciation for good food. While some may enjoy larger portions in lieu of the perfectly balanced dish, all of us are relatively adventurous eaters who really enjoy a good meal. Any suggestions for a great restaurant that we could still get a reservation for new years eve? We are pretty flexible with neighborhoods and our budget is $75 per person with drink(s). Atmosphere doesn't need to be super upscale, nor does it need to cater to the frat boy. Thanks for the suggestions.