We live in New York and go out quite a bit but I'm completely at a loss where to go for my husband's birthday. The problem is we've been to a LOT of restaurants!! Looking to make a 9pm ressie for Sunday night, I've narrowed it down to three we have never been to:
Craft - he loves Tom Collichio though we were horribly disappointed by a recent dinner at Collichio and Sons. The menu looks great but I'm undecided..
Blue Hill - I know this is a must-go at some point but not sure if this is birthday-worthy. From the photos it looks a little stuffy and boring...
Mas - never heard of this place until walked by it recently and it looked cute and romantic. Looked it up on Zagat and it gets a 27. The photos look romantic and sweet but not so sure about the menu.
If you've been to all three, please rate them in order on the following: food, romantic, and overall atmosphere/special experience.