I had one of the best and most romantic meals of my life when I went to Commander's Palace with my girlfriend two years ago. It was quite a different experience when we returned and tried to recreate the magic last week. We both ordered their tasting menu, and while nothing was terrible (nothing was amazing either), the food was plagued by stupid careless mistakes--many sharp jagged bits of shell in the crabcakes, sand in the bed of spinach on which they sat. I bit into a huge grapefruit seed in my weird citrus custard thingy. Am I overreacting? Has anyone else had a similar experience recently?
The space is still gorgeous, and the staff treated us very well. Today, I wrote them a polite letter telling them about the problems above. I would normally have told the staff right then and there, but it was our last night in town, it had been cold and rainy all week, and I just wanted the vacation to end on a positive note.