We gave Bazin's on Church a second try last night, but we won't be going again. It wasn't 'bad', it just wasn't good enough to make our list. My husband and I both agreed that if they fixed one or two of the problem areas, it might be ok but as is it just added up to a failure.
So, what were the problem areas you ask? Here's what we thought:
Our opentable reservation was for 5:30, so the restaurant was fairly empty when we arrived and quite full by the time we left.
Service was pretty lacking for a restaurant at this price point. Our 'main' waiter (the one who took our orders for dinner and dessert) was non-existent once the order was taken and his attitude while taking the orders was inattentive and rushed. My mother-in-law decided shortly after the main dishes were delivered that she'd like a glass of iced tea. It took 2 requests and probably 15 minutes for her to receive it. Service was pretty much 'drop and run'. We ordered a couple of appetizers to share and even though we indicated that when ordering and when the apps arrived, no individual plates were provided. We ended up crowding the apps onto our bread plates. Busboy tried to clear the apps before we were finished. Coffee arrived well after desserts and no refills were offered, even though cups were emptied before the desserts were finished.
As soon as the place started to fill the noise level became uncomfortably loud. I don't like having to raise my voice to be heard by my companions at a four-top. I know restaurants think the noise adds 'excitement' to their atmosphere, but I don't like it.
The food was just ok. We started with the Roasted Asparagus and the duck quesadilla. The asparagus tasted more steamed than roasted, though the accompanying mushrooms were quite tasty. The quesadilla was good, I especially liked the chipotle crema. I had the special of the evening, a blackened swordfish on roasted potato slices with corn (again with chipotles). The corn was terrific,sweet and smoky. Unfortunately, the swordfish was overly salty and slighlty overcooked. My husband had the veal milanese, it was underwhelming. While nicely flavored, the fried batter was too much and the greens on top too little. The dish was just not balanced..a big piece of fried veal and not much else. Also, it looked to me like the veal had been deep fried, not pan fried, though there was no indication of this on the menu. My mother-in-law had the scallops. She was pleased with them, though I noticed she left quite a lot of the accompanying sides pushed off to the side. Desserts were Apple cobbler, mixed-berry shortcake and chocolate torte. Nothing wrong, just nothing special either.
As I said, not 'bad', just not good enough.