A bit of a delay, but we went to Batifole for Winterlicious and were beyond impressed. We knew that trying it for the 1st time during Winterliscious would be risky, but have always felt that restos should see it as an opportunity to show their stuff.
The regular and Winterliscious menus were well thought out. 3 of us had the prix fixe, and one ate from the regular menu. The service was relaxed and excellent. The wine list was affordable and interesting, and the food was just great. Decor was relaxed and comfortable. To top it off, they served us 2 side orders of each frites and salad that was INCLUDED (!!) in the prix fixe price of only $25 pp. This was a nice contrast to other very skimpy Winterliscious offerings elsewhere (Eduardo's for one.....).
Terrine de canard - served with gherkins and crispy baguette slices - absolutely lovely; Celeriac soup, and Crab soup (the latter was only so so as the complaint was it was way too rich for the portion size).
Main: The 3 PF folks had the fish: a combo of striped bass and salmon in a lobster infused sauce presented in a small dish all baked together - YUM! The frites and salad were also excellent as sides (& plentiful!). The regular menu CH had the cassoulet - it was also terrific.
Desert: All had the creme brulee which was lovely.
We all can't wait to get back. I wanted to post this as a hopeful message to other restos that participate in Winterliscious - what we, the "first-timers", want is a reason to go back and pay full-price! Thanks to Batifole to adding 4 new regulars to their list!