We're going to be on Maui for our anniversary this year, and have lined up a sitter for our two young-ish kids. We're looking to book a special anniversary dinner, with three main factors:
1) the quality of the food (of course!),
2) the ambience (preferably not a room filled with kids, since we'll be on break from ours...), and
3) the convenience.
We're staying at the Sheraton in Kaanapali, and would like a non-driving option (so that we can both have wine). There's a free shuttle to Lahaina, but I assume that we can instead get a taxi pretty easily to/from the Kapalua area.
After reading through pages of past reviews on this board (as well as on other sites), it appears that the best option for us is the Pineapple Grill, where I have booked a reservation. Now, as we get closer, though, doubt is beginning to set in! Merriman's has been getting a lot of good posts, and I'm also intrigued by the Lahaina Grill. I *think* that Pacific'o and I'o are not the same level of quality, but their location on the water is very nice. I would very much welcome any thoughts/opinions. Thanks!