For last week in Sep .. 3 years ago I had a great vacation in New England. I went to Trenton Bridge Lobster Pound and I know I MUST go to Red's again; to me, it's worth the wait.
I'll probably try Young's in Belfast and Five Islands will only be open weekends so I can go there on Saturday. Heard great things about Thurston's in Bernard, too.
I'm debating whether I should to to Conte's in Rockland. I don't mind funky decor, but I want tasty food and this place gets mixed reviews.
Emphasis on lobster, casual settings, bang for the buck.