14 of 21
Ben & Jerry’s can claim to have invented this universally beloved flavor, since they offered it their shops starting in 1984. But they didn’t get the formula right for pints until 1991: We guess the wait was worth it, as it’s always among the best sellers. It seems so simple, but a base of good vanilla ice cream mixed with pieces of cookie dough? So indulgent, plus it’ll remind you of childhood.