The newly renovated Bi-Rite Creamery (now with seats, but the lines are as long as ever) may mark a high point for the new-school ice cream sundae. "The best sundae I have ever tasted," artemis declares. david kaplan recommends a combo of salted caramel ice cream, fudge, and salted Marcona almonds, and possibly a house-made brownie or cookie.
"The best of the best for me is a hot fudge sundae at Mitchell's" made with toasted almond ice cream, says sfkusinera. There's no seating at Mitchell's (unless you count one tiny bench outside), but the St. Francis ice cream parlor, always a good place for a sundae, has Mitchell's these days.
"For old-fashioned sundaes, nowhere else compares" to Fenton's Creamery, says cakebaker, especially with "old-fashioned" freshly whipped cream. But sfkusinera dings their "so-so ice cream and hot fudge," despite the nice atmosphere. The fudge isn't the topping to get here, counters Robert Lauriston. Stick to the caramel sauce.
Balboa Cafe makes a great sundae in which both the ice cream and hot fudge match in deliciousness, says Mari. "The fudge was like melted dark chocolate without the overly sweet taste of the Fenton's fudge."
myst says Loard's in the East Bay has tasty ice cream that's better than Fenton's, plus creative sundaes.
And finally, despite being a tourist trap with mediocre ice cream, Ghirardelli's hot fudge puts its ice cream sundae over the top, hounds say. "Not necessarily the best ice cream, but surely one of the best hot fudge sundaes I've ever had," says sfkusinera.
Bi-Rite Creamery [Mission]
3692 18th Street, San Francisco
Mitchell's Ice Cream [Noe Valley]
688 San Jose Avenue, San Francisco
St. Francis Fountain & Candy [Mission]
2801 24th Street, San Francisco
Fenton's Creamery [East Bay]
4226 Piedmont Avenue, Oakland
Balboa Cafe [Cow Hollow]
3199 Fillmore Street, San Francisco
Loard's Ice Cream & Candies [East Bay]
2265 S. Shore Center, Alameda
Loard's Ice Cream [East Bay]
3080 El Cerrito Plaza, El Cerrito
Ghirardelli Ice Cream and Chocolate [Fisherman's Wharf]
900 N. Point Street, San Francisco
Discuss: Hot Fudge Sundae in SF